12 Questions to Ask Before You Hire an SEO Company (and the Answers You Should Hear)

The short answer: Before you hire an SEO company, ask who will do the work, what you will own, how you can leave, what the monthly report shows, and how they will count phone calls instead of only rankings. A good company answers in plain words and puts it in writing. Anyone who guarantees first place on Google is telling you what you want to hear, because Google says no one can promise that.

SEO stands for search engine optimization. It is the work of helping Google understand your business so the right people can find you when they search.

If you run a roofing company, a pest control route, an HVAC shop, a cleaning crew, or a clinic, you have probably been pitched by someone who never explained what the money actually does. This list is for that moment.

Ask these questions on the call. Then ask for the answers by email. A company that is happy to write it down is usually a company that will do what it says. We are Flux Labs Agency, based in Port St. Lucie, Florida, and we would answer all twelve the same way. The questions apply wherever your business is.

1. Who will actually do the work on my account?

You should hear: a clear answer about who does what. A role is enough, such as "a local SEO specialist and a writer." If outside contractors touch your site, they should say so. You should also have one way to reach a real person.

Walk away if: the answer is "our team" and nothing more.

2. What will I own when this is over?

You should hear: "Everything that carries your business name." That means your domain name, your website, your Google Business Profile, and your Google Analytics and Search Console accounts, all in your name, with you as the owner. Our ownership checklist walks through each one.

Walk away if: they register your domain under their own name, run your Google listing only from their account, or say the site is "licensed" back to you.

This matters because the roles are not equal. On a Google Business Profile, only owners can remove other owners and managers. If the agency is the owner and you are the manager, they hold the keys.

3. How long is the contract, and how do I leave?

You should hear: the exact term in writing before you sign, a notice period in plain words, and a handoff. Your files, logins, and content go with you.

Walk away if: the term is vague, there is a surprise fee to exit, and no mention of what you get back. Ask what happens to the website the day you leave.

For comparison, our general terms are public in our MSA, and the term for any monthly service is written on your order form before you sign anything.

4. What exactly do I get each month?

You should hear: a list. Pages written or fixed, listing updates, technical fixes, review work, and a report. Each item should be something you could check.

Walk away if: the answer is "ongoing optimization" and you cannot tell what you paid for in a given month.

5. What will be in the monthly report?

You should hear: calls, form leads, and where they came from. What was done this month. What is planned next. All in plain English, with a sample report you can see before you sign.

Walk away if: the report is a pile of charts and jargon, or the only number is rankings.

6. How will you count phone calls, not just rankings?

You should hear: a plan to track calls and form leads in an account you can open. Rankings are a clue, not the goal. A business can rank well for a phrase that no customer ever types.

Ask them to show you how a call gets counted while your real phone number stays the same everywhere online. If your number changes from page to page, the tracking is creating a new problem.

Walk away if: the only proof is "you are on page one." Page one for what?

7. Why can't an honest SEO guarantee first place on Google?

Because they do not control Google. Google's own advice on hiring an SEO says no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and it treats that kind of promise as a reason to find someone else. For local results, Google also says you cannot pay for a better local ranking.

You should hear: what they will promise instead. Work done on schedule. Honest estimates of what is realistic. Clear reports. A straight answer when something is not working.

Our client terms say the same thing: we do not promise number one rankings, a set number of leads, or a guaranteed return.

8. How long before I see results?

You should hear: an honest range and a first-month plan. Google's own guide says some changes show up within hours and others can take several months, and it suggests waiting a few weeks before judging whether a change helped. You can read that in the SEO Starter Guide.

Walk away if: you are promised page one in 30 days.

9. What access do you need, and at what level?

You should hear: "We will ask to be added as a user, and you stay the owner." Google advises granting only read access to Search Console while someone is doing an audit, and no write access at that stage.

Google also lets you add people to a Business Profile with their own accounts, so nobody needs your password.

Walk away if: they ask for your personal login or want to be the account owner.

10. What will you change, and will you explain it?

You should hear: a plan in plain words, with reasons. Google suggests asking whether the SEO follows its published rules (called Search Essentials) and will share every change and the reasoning behind it. You also should never have to link to your SEO from your site.

Walk away if: it is a "secret method," a link scheme, or a promise to submit your site to thousands of search engines. Google calls those typically useless.

Remember that you are responsible for what the companies you hire do in your name.

11. Can I talk to some of your past clients?

You should hear: "Yes," or "Here is work we can show you, with the owner's permission." Google recommends checking references: ask whether the client found the service useful, easy to work with, and effective.

Walk away if: they cannot show any real example, or all they show is a screenshot of rankings.

12. What do you need from me, and how will we talk?

You should hear: a short list. Photos, a few customer questions, approvals, and access. Plus a clear way to reach them and a normal wait time for replies.

A good SEO company also asks about you. Your best jobs, the towns you serve, who you compete with, and how customers find you.

Walk away if: they never ask about your business.

What are the red flags when hiring an SEO company?

Watch for these:

• A promise of first place on Google, a "special relationship" with Google, or a "priority submit."
• They own, or want to own, your domain, website, or Google Business Profile.
• Reports that are vague, full of jargon, or only show rankings.
• A contract term nobody will put in writing, with no exit and no handoff.
• Secrecy about what they change.
• Pressure to link to them, or link-buying schemes.
• No interest in your business, your towns, or your customers.

How can I check an SEO company's work?

You do not need to be technical. Try these:

• Search your business name and your main service plus your town. Do it in a private window and look at what shows up.
• Open your Google Business Profile and confirm you are listed as an owner.
• Ask for before-and-after examples, then look at those pages yourself.
• Keep your own call log for a month. Do the calls match the report?
• Ask for reports from accounts you can open, not only a PDF.
• Get a second opinion before you renew.

Common questions

Do I even need an SEO company?

Maybe not. Google's own guidance says that if you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself. Hiring makes the most sense when you do not have the time, or when you are building or redesigning your site.

What should SEO cost?

It depends on what is included, so we do not put numbers in blog posts. Ask any company for a written scope and a list of anything billed separately. We scope after a free audit.

Is SEO the same as getting found in ChatGPT?

They overlap, but they are not the same. We cover the second one in how to get your business recommended by ChatGPT. The first one is on our SEO and local SEO pages.

Want a second pair of eyes?

If you are comparing companies, or you want to see where you stand before you hire anyone, we will look at your setup for free. It is useful even if we never work together, and you get plain answers about what is helping and what is not.

Get my free audit